Shelley starred alongside George Segal and JoBeth Williams in the 1992 comedy Me, Myself and I. She played Jennifer, a closeted lesbian who was a Hollywood superstar and married to successful screen writer and novelist Buddy Arnett (Segal.) Afraid of being outed and losing her career, she constantly pleaded Buddy for photo ops to perpetuate her straight image, but, in reality, she was in a lesbian relationship.